Law Merchant and Admiralty (Distinguished)
Law merchant and admiralty are routinely merged in the sovereignty literature — and they are genuinely related, sharing civilian roots and a non-common-law origin. But they are different kinds of thing. Admiralty is a jurisdiction: a constitutional grant, a dedicated federal forum, and its own procedure. The law merchant is a body of substantive commercial doctrine, absorbed into the ordinary courts and codified as the UCC. Admiralty answers which court and what procedure; the law merchant answers which rules govern the deal. Keeping the two apart is what lets 'the UCC is in control' be supported while 'the courts are operating in admiralty' stays foreclosed.
Jun 3, 2026